Baseball and Playing Indian
Responses to the installation


installation display
Above: A display from the installation.
Click to see an enlarged view.

Right, detail: The mascot memorabilia from popular culture overpowers the black and white photograph of Charlene Teters, not allowing American Indians to be "seen as real people".

Photo by Roderick Mickens
detail of installation display

Do you think the use of American Indian mascots by sports teams and elsewhere in the media is a respectful gesture, or a stereotype?
Here's what people said...
Responses
The statements on this site are those of the artist and of visitors. They do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Museum.
Elliot, a 6th grade student:
"I think she has a point about the images being racist."
Shamecca, a 2nd grade student:
"I would like to say that she was smart enough to protest."
LeRon McKendrick, from Atlanta, GA:
"I am a strong advocate that the use of American Indian culture should not be mocked through the use of sports teams as mascots. Being a native of Atlanta, GA, and an African-American, I have grown up around the prejudices and mockery of both the Native-Indian and African cultures. I hope that the fight continues for the American Indian descendants and all other ethnic groups that have become subjects of North America's ignorance."
Paul, 14 years old, from Bennington:
"Interesting exhibit - Sometimes I forget that judging a person though the images that are forced upon is not the way the Native American Indians want to be viewed. I also think that the fans who portray certain images don't believe they are being disrespectful, they are just having a good time, supporting their team."
Heather and Stan, college juniors from Brooklyn, NY:
"This program raised my awareness to the issue of racial inequality and bias against Native Americans. The negative things that are portrayed against them would never be portrayed about other races. We wish you luck with your cause."
Santiago Valencia:
"It is important to know about other cultures and I think that this was an interesting presentation. Please continue doing this work."
Phyllis Shapiro, over 60, from Long Island City:
"I feel that the logos and all the caricatures and the mascots are indeed extremely offensive, and stereotypical. But, I think if all of these were removed and only the names remain it would be acceptable. After all, the names are so ingrained in our culture that it would be difficult to change them and still retain who they are."
Aeneas from Derby:
"I think it is amazing in the first part of the twenty-first century that images that are derogatory to a culture, which predates the Declaration of Independence, are still acceptable. It is time for sports franchises, colleges and schools to realize that just because a mascot has been used for decades does not mean it is not racist."
Anne Connor-Schisler, 44, from Claremont, California:
"As a Canadian, I have grown up with a vision of a cultural mosaic for all people in my homeland. I abhor the use of symbols for profit when it victimizes those that it symbolizes."
Nancy Morton from Greensboro, NC:
"We all need to be more sensitive to the feelings and heritage of those other than ourselves, especially since 9/11. It is too easy to dismiss this type of stereotyping behavior as innocent when it is actually ignorance that spawns it."
Search  divider  Site map  divider  FAQ  divider  Copyright  divider  Privacy policy  divider  Rose Center  divider  Contact us  divider  Sign up for eNotes