Eric       Got Cats? Get Worms!
Young Naturalist Awards Back to 2005 Winners
Continued...

Questions Year 1

Experiment A: What is the best ratio of worms to food (cat feces)?
Experiment B: What is the best ratio of nitrogen to carbon in the system?
Experiment C: What is the best feeding frequency for the system?

Method Year 1 (measurements or tests required)

1. Cat health (parasite level in stool culture when no antiparasite medication is used)
2. Ambient weather conditions
3. Weight of cat waste per cat per day
4. Weight of vermicomposting systems and control bins, weekly
5. Worm count and weight (one pound of worms equals 1,000 worms.)
6. Bedding temperature weekly (adjusted to be the same as ambient temperatures in the house)
7. Bedding moisture, daily
8. PH of bedding, weekly
9. Soil tests of the cat waste, wet newspaper, and peat moss for nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium content. Then tests of the vermicomposting bins for N, P, and K weekly.
10. E. coli counts (initially, cat waste, wet newspaper, and peat moss. Then weekly E. coli counts of vermicomposting system bins.)
11. Control bin (set up identically and presented to control cat three times on the first day of experiment; control cat was not treated with any antiparasite medication)

Variables Year 2

1. Selamectin (trade name Revolution; made by Phizer), applied topically once to all 10 cats at recommended dose
2. Leuferon (trade name Program Suspension; Novaritis), given orally once to all 10 cats at recommended dose
3. Milbemycin (trade name Interceptor Flavor Tabs; Novaritis), given orally once to all 10 cats at recommended dose
4. Ivomectin (trade name Heartgard Chewables for Cats; Merck), given orally once to all 10 cats at recommended dose
5. Fipronil + Methoprene (trade name Frontline TopSpot Plus; Merial), given topically once to all 10 cats at recommended dose
6. Imidacloprid (trade name Advantage Topical Solution; Bayer), given topically once to all 10 cats at recommended dose
7. Fipronil (trade name Frontline Spray; Merial), applied topically once to all 10 cats at recommended dose
8. Phenothrin + Methoprene (trade name Flea & Tick Drops Plus; Hartz), given topically once to all 10 cats at recommended dose
9. Pyriproxyfen (trade name PreTect; Sergeant's), applied topically once to all 10 cats at recommended dose

Method Year 2

The same measurements were taken of temperature, pH, soil conditions, bin weight, worm count, and coliform count as described for Year 1.

Discussion and Analysis

The vermicomposting project was divided into five parts and involved two years of observations. In Year 1, I established the optimum conditions for vermicomposting cat wastes with three basic experiments and hundreds of measurements. I found that the most important factors in creating a good environment for the worms were the level of moisture, the amount of aeration, and achieving the proper carbon-to-nitrogen ratio. The worms were able to adapt to slow changes in temperature and pH.

The worms, of course, asked, "What's for dinner?" Since Eisenia fetida manure worms will make use of almost any carbon and nitrogen source as food, the worms were not picky about cat waste. It is a common misconception that worms "eat" waste. The worms get their nutrition from the bacterial, fungal, and protozoal activity in the vermicomposting system. Since the worms have no teeth or digestive enzymes, the microorganisms "predigest" the worm's food and then become food themselves.

Chart 1: E. coli Colonies in 3 ounces ADP.
Chart 1: E. coli Colonies in 3 ounces ADP (Click to enlarge)
The end point of the composting was established when the E. coli colony count declined, indicating that the cats' fecal material had been decomposed. Comparison of colony counts was done by counting the number of E. coli colonies from an aliquot sample and then calculating the number of E. coli that would be represented in three ounces of cat waste (the ADP, or "average daily poop"). E. coli counts were taken on the vermicomposting bins on a weekly schedule.

(Coliform bacteria are a group of bacteria that are all of fecal origin and are normal in the intestinal tract but can also be pathological. Escherichia coli is the best-known coliform; Salmonella is probably the best-known coliform pathogen. I established that my cats did not have any pathogenic coliforms by having a diagnostic lab perform a culture on a composite stool sample.)

The E. coli colony count was reduced by 33%, 50%, and 88% by weeks 4, 5, and 7. I had read about municipal human-sewage systems in which 10,000 pounds of worms "ate" 10,000 pounds of sewage sludge in one week, and the coliform reduction was about 50%. The E. coli reduction of 88% in my system exceeded my expectations. It was also noted that the initially acidic system moderated to pH 6-7, and the nitrogen level was high at the end point.

Eric working with shredded newspaper.
Eric working with shredded newspaper
Although worms adjust to changing temperatures, I maintained the system at 70° F, and the worms efficiently composted the feces in just two weeks. The optimum conditions achieved were when the weight of the worms equaled the weight of daily cat feces (ADP); the amount of carbon material present (shredded newspaper) was in a 2:1 ratio to the nitrogen material present (cat feces, or ADP); and daily feeding was performed. (It was awkward in class to continue to refer to cat feces, so I devised the acronym ADP to stand for "average daily poops." ADP doesn't provoke a gag response from the audience.)


SEARCH SITE MAP FAQ COPYRIGHT INFO PRIVACY POLICY ROSE CENTER CONTACT US SIGN UP FOR AMNH ENOTES