Early Mammals Developed in Surprisingly Different Ways

by AMNH on

News & Blogs

Artist rendering of a small, furry mammal with sharp teeth clings to a leafy tree branch with its pointy-clawed feet. An artist’s reconstruction of Arboroharamiya, an early, likely tree-dwelling euharamiyidan mammal that had a layered bone structure like that found in modern placental mammals.
© Chuang Zhao
How did the earliest mammals grow? Did they develop slowly, like reptiles, or quickly, like many small mammals today?

A new study led by Museum paleontologists and published in the journal Proceedings B addresses these questions by looking inside the fossilized bones of mammals that lived alongside dinosaurs during the Jurassic, more than 145 million years ago.

The findings reveal that early mammals had a much wider range of growth and developmental strategies than previously recognized, with some taking years to reach adulthood and others developing in ways remarkably similar to modern placental mammals, including humans.

“Bones keep a record of how animals grow up. Just like trees have rings that show how many years they grew, bones also have these annual growth lines,” said Zoe Kulik, a research associate at the Museum and a postdoctoral researcher at the New York Institute of Technology, “Marsupials and placentals also layer their bone differently as they grow up, so those patterns tell us what kind of baby an extinct mammal started out as and how it grew up.”

Using thin sections of fossil bone and X-ray imaging at the European Synchrotron Radiation Facility in Grenoble, France, the research team examined a large set of bone samples from extinct early mammals. They uncovered striking differences in how mammals developed and gleaned new insights into how reproductive strategies seen in modern mammals may have first emerged.

For example, growth marks in the bones of Borealestes, from an extinct order of small, rodent-like animals called docodonts, show that it took them at least 5 to 6 years to grow to the size of a hamster. This is a slow and gradual pace, more similar to the growth of reptiles than modern small mammals, which can reach adulthood in just a few weeks.

In contrast, euharamiyidans, a group of tree-dwelling mammals from China, have a distinctive three-layered bone structure. Among living mammals, this structure is found only in placentals, which have long pregnancies and give birth to relatively well-developed young.

This suggests that euharamiyidans likely started out as well-developed babies and were weaned after about 30 days, similar to living rodents. This placental-like style of development evolved independently in euharamiyidans and was already present around 160 million years ago, much earlier than previously thought. 

“Our findings overturn the long-standing idea that mammal reproduction evolved in a simple progression, from egg-laying to marsupial-like to placental-like development,” said co-author Jin Meng, a curator in the Museum’s Division of Paleontology. “Instead, early mammals were experimenting with different developmental strategies long before placental mammals existed.”

“The way we and other placentals develop turns out not to be unique,” Kulik said. “Something similar evolved in other mammal groups at least 100 million years earlier.”

Paleontologists have long known that mammals underwent a remarkable ecological radiation during the Jurassic period, evolving into a variety of forms adapted for climbing, gliding, swimming and burrowing. This new study shows that this diversification extended beyond how mammals looked and where they lived: it also included how they grew, matured, and reproduced.