Handling and Sampling
Alvaro Keding/© AMNH
Handling
Humans are the most common cause of specimen loss and damage. Even fossils that appear robust can have areas of weakness or cracks that may not be readily apparent. If you regularly handle fossil specimens, there’s a good chance that you may end up damaging one. This can happen before you even touch the specimen—opening cabinets, drawers, or moving trays can put a specimen at risk.
Following these basic handling procedures (and making sure that your colleagues and visitors are aware of them too) can greatly reduce the risk of causing damage.
- When you open a cabinet, check carefully before slowly pulling out any drawers. Often specimens are tightly packed and are in contact with the bottom of the drawer above.
- If you must remove an entire drawer, make sure that you can support the weight of the drawer before doing so. Drawers sometimes differ in depth – pull the drawer out slowly and be aware of when you are nearing the end of the runner.
- Fossil specimens are often both fragile and heavy. Before you pick one up, think about how you will lift it. Is it light or heavy; are some parts of it more fragile or weakly attached than others?
- Never examine a specimen in a place where it can fall all the way to the floor. Hold it above a drawer, or tabletop, so that it has less far to fall if you drop it, and where you could easily find it.
- Think about how you put specimens down. Don’t let the full weight of the specimen rest on a fragile structure.
- With a larger specimen, try lifting the object an inch or so clear of the surface, then immediately put it down. This will give you a sense of any weaknesses, instability or flex in the specimen.
- With heavy specimens, make sure you have cleared the area that you are moving them to before you pick them up. Make sure you are capable of lifting the specimen alone, and ask for help if you are in any doubt.
- When working on heavier specimens, always lay a sheet of Ethafoam, or other cushioning material down on the tabletop for the specimen to rest on.
- Don’t leave specimens out for prolonged periods of time – it increases the risk of accidental damage.
- Never force a specimen back into a box, drawer, or cabinet. Take the time to make sure it fits properly.
Sampling
The development of new techniques in physical sciences and molecular biology has greatly increased the range of information that can be obtained beyond visual examination of a specimen. They may improve the accuracy with which specimens can be dated; provide information on the diet of extinct species; or allow researchers to add molecular data from DNA sequences to studies of phylogenetics.
Some of these processes, however, may require the destruction of a small part of the specimen and, if not done properly, could be the cause of more extensive damage or deterioration. These techniques are known collectively as “destructive sampling”.
The benefits of these types of study may outweigh the cost in damage to the specimen, but to ensure that this is not done wastefully the specimen owner should make sure that anyone requiring permission to sample from a specimen:
- has the right skills to collect the sample while minimizing any collateral damage.
- is able to get the required results from the collected sample.
- will publish the results in a timely manner.
- Sampling of subfossil bone or mummified tissue for molecular studies
- Sectioning of specimen teeth or bones
- Drilling of tooth enamel for isotopic studies
- Coating of specimens (or parts of specimens) for scanning electron microscope imaging
- Disarticulation of mounted specimens
- Separation of elements that have been glued together
- Some preparation methods (e.g., “lost fossil preparation”)
At a minimum, any request to carry out destructive sampling should include the following information:
- The purpose of the research and its scientific merit
- The sampling methods to be employed
- Why the chosen protocol is the least intrusive method possible
- Evidence of the researcher’s competence with the protocol
- The specimens to be sampled
- Why the specimens in question are essential to the study, and why these particular specimens are the best or only ones available for these purposes
- Provision of preliminary data indicating that the methods should be successful with the material requested
You should be satisfied that the following criteria have been met:
- The research is of sufficient scientific merit to justify destructive sampling
- Adequate justification has been given for the use of the specimen(s) in question
- The protocol will not significantly compromise future use of the specimen(s)
- The researcher has sufficient experience and expertise to successfully complete the proposed work
- The sampling will result in research publication(s) in a timely fashion
Type specimens should not be made available for destructive sampling. Sampling of specimens that are comparatively rare, either within the collection or generally, is also not advisable unless a particularly compelling case has been made.
Uncataloged material should not be sampled, because of the difficulties in ensuring accurate citation and attribution of samples when study results are published. For this reason, all sampled specimens must be cataloged first. It is important to consider the staff time and other resource implications of this cataloging when assessing the proposal.
The investigator should be able to provide reasonable assurance that the results of the study will be published in a peer-reviewed academic journal in a timely fashion, and a copy of these papers must be sent after publication. This information should then be recorded in any relevant databases and archives.
These Collection Management resources were originally developed in 2007 with the support of the National Science Foundation (NSF).